In this article8 sections
  1. The Rule Is Simple: Affected People Can Ask Why
  2. Who Is Covered and When
  3. What the Explanation Must Actually Contain
  4. Article 86 and GDPR: They Work Together
  5. What a Weak Response Looks Like
  6. Sample Response Templates for HR Teams
  7. Three Practical Steps to Get Ready
  8. References

The Rule Is Simple: Affected People Can Ask Why

The AI Act Article 86 right to explanation gives a person who is subject to a decision taken by a deployer on the basis of the output of a high-risk AI system the right to obtain clear and meaningful explanations of the role the AI system played in the decision-making procedure and of the main elements of the decision. It applies where the decision produces legal effects, or similarly significantly affects the person in a way they consider adverse to their health, safety or fundamental rights. This is not a vague aspiration buried in a recital. It is an individual right, and the answer has to come from you as the deployer, in contexts like recruitment, employee evaluation, credit scoring, or benefits assessment.

Article 86 sits in Chapter IX of the Act, among the remedies, but it only works for high-risk AI systems listed in Annex III. Since the Digital Omnibus on AI (Regulation (EU) 2026/1744), the rules for those systems in Chapter III apply from 2 December 2027. Whether Article 86 can be invoked before that date is not settled, so plan to be ready by 2 December 2027 at the latest. If your company uses an AI-assisted applicant tracking system, an automated CV screener, or a performance scoring tool, this right will apply to you.

Who Is Covered and When

Article 86 applies to natural persons. That means employees, job applicants, customers, and any individual affected by a decision based on output from a high-risk AI system listed in Annex III of the AI Act, with the exception of critical infrastructure systems (Annex III, point 2).

The scope is broader than many compliance officers initially expect. Annex III covers, among others:

  • Recruitment and selection of natural persons (including CV screening, ranking, and interview analysis tools)

  • Decisions affecting terms of employment, promotion, and termination

  • Access to education and vocational training

  • Creditworthiness assessment of natural persons

  • Eligibility for public assistance benefits and services

The decision is taken by the deployer "on the basis of" the AI output. The text does not require the decision to be fully automated, so a decision in which a human relied on the AI output can fall within it. The explanation is about the role the AI played in the overall decision-making process.

Timing matters too. The right concerns a decision that has been taken. There is no pre-decision consultation right under Article 86. Article 86 also applies only to the extent the right is not already provided for under other Union law, so where GDPR Article 22 and the GDPR information rights already give an explanation, those come first.

What the Explanation Must Actually Contain

The AI Act does not let you satisfy this obligation with a boilerplate letter. The explanation must be clear and meaningful. Under Article 86 it must cover:

  1. The role the AI system played in the decision-making procedure

  2. The main elements of the decision taken

In practice, a meaningful explanation usually names the main factors the system assessed, what the system's output was, and how that output fed into the final decision. The Act does not require you to disclose the relative weight of each factor, trade secrets or proprietary model weights.

You cannot hide behind vendor opacity, though. Providers of high-risk systems must give deployers instructions for use under Article 13, including information that helps deployers interpret the system's output. Use that information to construct a genuine explanation. If your vendor cannot provide it, that is a procurement problem to solve before 2 December 2027.

Article 86 and GDPR: They Work Together

If you operate in the Netherlands or Belgium, you already know the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens and the APD/GBA take automated decision-making seriously under GDPR Article 22. Article 86 of the AI Act runs alongside that framework, not instead of it.

GDPR Article 22 covers decisions based solely on automated processing with legal or similarly significant effects. The AI Act's Article 86 right can also reach decisions where a human is involved but relied on the AI output. In practice, for HR teams, this means:

  • A rejected job applicant may have rights under GDPR (Article 22 if the rejection was fully automated, and the GDPR information and access rights in any case) and, for high-risk AI, an AI Act Article 86 right

  • One well-designed explanation can serve both regimes

  • Your data protection officer should be involved in designing the template responses

Keep documentation. The GDPR requires you to be able to demonstrate compliance, and a contemporaneous record of each explanation provided is your evidence in the event of a complaint to a supervisory authority.

What a Weak Response Looks Like

Here is the kind of response that will create problems:

"Your application was reviewed using our standard recruitment process. We received many strong applications and have decided to proceed with other candidates."

This tells the applicant nothing about the AI's role. It does not acknowledge the system was used. It does not explain the main elements of the decision. For a decision based on a high-risk AI system, it does not meet Article 86.

Article 86 is not in the fine tiers of Article 99. How a failure to explain is sanctioned is left to national law under Article 99(1), which allows fines, warnings and non-monetary measures. A poor answer also invites a GDPR complaint, a discrimination claim, or both.

Sample Response Templates for HR Teams

You should have at least two templates ready: one for rejected applicants and one for employees subject to performance or promotion decisions.

Template 1 — Rejected Applicant

Dear [Name], Thank you for applying for the role of [Position]. We want to be transparent about our process. We used an AI-assisted screening tool during initial shortlisting. In your case, the system assessed the following factors: [list, e.g. relevant experience duration, keyword alignment with the job description, qualifications match]. The main factor in your case was [specific factor]. The system's output indicated [outcome, e.g. a below-threshold match score] and this output informed our recruiter's decision not to advance your application. If you would like to discuss this further or provide additional context, please contact [name/email] within 30 days.

Template 2 — Employee Performance Decision

Dear [Name], As discussed on [date], your [performance review / promotion assessment] outcome was [result]. We are writing to confirm the role our AI-assisted evaluation tool played in that process. The tool assessed [factors, e.g. output metrics over the review period, attendance data, peer review scores]. The main factors influencing the AI's output were [list]. Our [manager title] reviewed this output and made the final decision, taking [additional context] into account. You have the right to request further information about this process. Please contact [HR contact] if you wish to do so.

Adapt these to your specific system and sector. The key requirement is specificity: name the AI's role, the main factors, and the system's output.

Three Practical Steps to Get Ready

Step 1: Map your AI systems against Annex III. Identify every tool your company uses in HR, credit, benefits, or access decisions. If it scores, ranks, or recommends decisions about people, it likely qualifies.

Step 2: Talk to your vendors. Request the instructions for use and documentation of the factors their systems use. Ask them explicitly: can you support our Article 86 obligations? Get the answer in writing and make it a contractual term going forward.

Step 3: Prepare and test your templates. Draft responses for each AI-assisted decision type, run them past your DPO or legal counsel, and train the HR staff who will send them. Do a dry run with a fictional applicant to find gaps before a real request arrives.

Article 86 is one of the clearest individual rights in the AI Act, and one of the most actionable for HR teams. Plan to be ready by 2 December 2027 at the latest, which leaves enough time to do it properly.

Run the free 2-minute compliance check at comply.khairos.ai to see which obligations apply to your specific AI tools and get a prioritised action list tailored to your company size and sector.

References

  1. Article 86 of the AI Act

  2. Article 26 of the AI Act

  3. Annex III

  4. Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 (Digital Omnibus on AI)

  5. Article 13

  6. Article 99

  7. comply.khairos.ai

Not sure where your company stands?

Answer 15 questions about how your team uses AI. You get a compliance score and the gaps to close first, as a PDF.

Am I compliant? Check in 2 minHow Khairos Comply works